"The Scream"
by Edvard Munch
Critique from an imitationalist's point of view.
Edvard Munch's art is generally known for being full of emotions like fear, isolation, and anxiety, its imitationalist qualities, however, are quite lacking. The Scream is very emotionally expressive, yet still unsatisfying from an imitationalist's point of view because it is unrealistic. The proportions of the person in the foreground are really exaggerated and inaccurately sized, the colors are bland and unrealistic and the background scene is lacking depth and perspective. As an imitationalist artist, I think this painting is horrible.
Critique from an emotionalist's point of view.
This piece of art was obviously made to invoke negative emotions such as the aforementioned fear, isolation, and anxiety. This is the kind of art work that gives you a panic attack when you look at it. Munch did an amazing job at capturing the key facial features of panic and displaying them on the subject. The man has widely open eyes and mouth, long clenching hands gripping his head, and a curving frail body. The two figures in the left middle ground are also quite emotionally inflictive, they lack detail and are hard to examine, yet you still find your eyes repeatedly drawn towards them, invoking paranoia. As an emotionalist artist, I found this work of art spectacular.
Edvard Munch's art is generally known for being full of emotions like fear, isolation, and anxiety, its imitationalist qualities, however, are quite lacking. The Scream is very emotionally expressive, yet still unsatisfying from an imitationalist's point of view because it is unrealistic. The proportions of the person in the foreground are really exaggerated and inaccurately sized, the colors are bland and unrealistic and the background scene is lacking depth and perspective. As an imitationalist artist, I think this painting is horrible.
Critique from an emotionalist's point of view.
This piece of art was obviously made to invoke negative emotions such as the aforementioned fear, isolation, and anxiety. This is the kind of art work that gives you a panic attack when you look at it. Munch did an amazing job at capturing the key facial features of panic and displaying them on the subject. The man has widely open eyes and mouth, long clenching hands gripping his head, and a curving frail body. The two figures in the left middle ground are also quite emotionally inflictive, they lack detail and are hard to examine, yet you still find your eyes repeatedly drawn towards them, invoking paranoia. As an emotionalist artist, I found this work of art spectacular.
Critique from a formalist's point of view.
This picture has great flow, although simplistic, it gets you to follow the water and then land and focus on the two mysterious figures in the far left. The balance is also very good yet simplistic; the right land mass with the bridge balances well with the more weighted left land mass, horizontally, and with the sky, vertically. Due to it's simplicity there is not much rhythm in this picture but it is very even and well laid out. The perspective on the bridge made with the line flow is also amazing, but line flow in the land and water are really messy. I think the movement could have been made even better, had Munch made the lines better -- mainly in the right land mass. The colors work well with each other but are very bland and uninteresting. I think this picture is very good mostly because of its amazing movement and balance.
No comments:
Post a Comment